When Saudi General Khalid bin Sultan bin Abdul Aziz went shopping in the late 1980s for Chinese medium-range missiles capable of carrying nuclear, chemical or biological warheads he made no bones about keeping the United States, one of the kingdom’s closest allies, in the dark.
It was “my task to negotiate the deal, devise an appropriate deception plan, choose a team of Saudi officers and men and arrange for their training in both Saudi Arabia and China, build and defend operation bases and storage facilities in different parts of the kingdom, arrange for the shipment of the missiles from China and, at every stage, be ready to defend the project against sabotage or any form of attack,” General Bin Sultan, a son of the late Saudi crown prince and defence minister, Sultan bin Abdul Aziz al Saud, and commander of the US-led international alliance that forced Iraq to withdraw from Kuwait in 1991, recounted in his memoire.
The incident coupled with more recent Saudi statements and the kingdom’s inability to present from the outset a credible and sustainable version of events surrounding the killing of journalist Jamal Khashoggi on the premises of its Istanbul consulate is complicating it’s negotiations with the United States for the acquisition of designs for nuclear power plants, a deal valued at up to US$80 billion depending on how many Saudi Arabia ultimately decides to build.
Prospects of a massive deal go to the heart of US President Donald J. Trump’s jobs and deals-focused America First policy. Yet, growing criticism and distrust of Saudi Arabia in the US Congress and intelligence community as a result of the Khashoggi crisis and the kingdom’s handling of the Yemen war that has sparked the world’s worst humanitarian crisis since World War Two are likely to strengthen efforts to thwart an agreement that honours Saudi insistence on producing its own nuclear fuel, even though it could buy it more cheaply abroad.
The Saudi insistence has fuelled concerns that the kingdom may divert their fuel for military purposes. Those kinds of fears coupled with Iran’s ballistic missile program drove world powers to first sanction Iran and then conclude a 2015 international agreement that curbed Iran’s nuclear program. Trump withdrew from the agreement earlier this year, charging that it did not provide sufficient guarantees that Iran would not be able to develop a nuclear weapon.
Democrats in the US Congress have described refusing to sell Saudi Arabia nuclear technology as proper punishment for the killing of Khashoggi that the kingdom insists was done without the knowledge of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. While the Trump administration has as yet not abandoned long-standing strict US nuclear export safeguards to secure a deal with Saudi Arabia, it has also not unambiguously said that it would uphold them.
Like with his rejection of hard-hitting sanctions in the wake of the Khashoggi killing, Trump is likely to ultimately argue that if the United States does not conclude a nuclear deal with Saudi Arabia, countries like China, Russia and South Korea, that have less strict controls will. The argument amounts to the equivalent of committing a wrong because if one doesn’t, someone else will.
Saudi officials have repeatedly insisted that the kingdom is developing nuclear capabilities for peaceful purposes such as medicine, electricity generation, and desalination of sea water. They say that Saudi Arabia is committed to putting its future facilities under the supervision of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
Yet, with a US$56 billion military budget for 2018, Saudi Arabia is stepping up the development of a domestic military industry. The kingdom aims to source 50% of its military procurement domestically by 2030, up from its current two percent. Speaking to CBS earlier this year, Prince Mohammed appeared to put conditions on Saudi nuclear assurances by warning that “Saudi Arabia does not want to acquire any nuclear bomb, but without a doubt, if Iran developed a nuclear bomb, we will follow suit as soon as possible.”
In putting forward demands for parity with Iran by getting the right to controlled enrichment of uranium and the reprocessing of spent fuel into plutonium, potential building blocks for nuclear weapons, Saudi Arabia was also seen as potentially backing away from a 2009 memorandum of understanding with the United States in which it pledged to acquire nuclear fuel from international markets.
Nuclear energy cooperation was one of a host of agreements concluded last year by Saudi Arabia and China during a visit to Beijing by Saudi King Salman. The agreement included a feasibility study for the construction of high-temperature gas-cooled (HTGR) nuclear power plants in the kingdom as well as cooperation in intellectual property and the development of a domestic industrial supply chain for HTGRs built in Saudi Arabia. The HTGR agreement built on an accord signed in 2012 that involved maintenance and development of nuclear power plants and research reactors, as well as the provision of Chinese nuclear fuel.
A report by the Washington-based Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS) released shortly after the king’s visit warned that the 2015 Iran nuclear agreement had “not eliminated the kingdom’s desire for nuclear weapons capabilities and even nuclear weapons.” Much like the era of General Bin Sultan, potential Chinese sales to Saudi Arabia of ballistic missiles and cruise missiles remain one of the murkier areas of Sino-Saudi military cooperation.
Military experts say that satellite imagery of missile bases in Saudi Arabia in recent years and other open-source circumstantial evidence, including Saudi press coverage of graduation ceremonies at the kingdom’s Strategic Missile Force school in Wadi ad-Dawasir, attest to ongoing transfers.
Saudi Arabia in 2014 showcased Chinese-made Dongfeng-3 missiles that have a range of up to 5,000 kilometres. Media reports said the missiles had been purchased in 2007, possibly with US acquiescence. “Saudi Arabia has invested heavily in conventional ballistic and cruise missiles to provide the kingdom a shot of strategic deterrence,” said non-proliferation expert Jeffrey Lewis. Lewis’ conclusion was confirmed by Anwar Eshqi, a retired Saudi major general and advisor to the Saudi military.
“The Saudi military did indeed receive DF-21 missiles from China and the integration of the missiles, including a full maintenance check and upgraded facilities, is complete, “Eshqi said referring to the People’s Republic’s East Wind solid-fuel, medium-range ballistic missile.
Note: This article was originally published in the blog, The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer and has been reproduced under arrangement. Web link
As part of its editorial policy, the MEI@ND standardizes spelling and date formats to make the text uniformly accessible and stylistically consistent. The views expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views/positions of the MEI@ND. Editor, MEI@ND: P R Kumaraswamy
James M. Dorsey is a Senior Fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies as Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, co-director of the Institute of Fan Culture of the University of Würzburg, and the author of the blog, The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer. Email: jmdorsey@questfze.com
The final run-up to the 2022 World Cup and the tournament's management is make-it-or-break-it ti.....
Former Qatari emir Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani, the father of the Gulf state's current ruler, Tam.....
The Biden administration is mulling whether to grant Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman sovereig.....
Qatar's 2022 World Cup promises to benefit not only itself but also to provide an unintended eco.....
A potential revival of the Iran nuclear accord is likely to test the sustainability of Middle Easter.....
With the fate hanging in the balance of the 2015 international agreement that curbed Iran’s nu.....
At first glance, there is little that Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, an Islamist and nation.....
Europe is likely to shoulder the brunt of the fallout of a rapidly escalating crisis over Ukraine. M.....
An Israeli NGO gives the United Arab Emirates high marks for mandating schoolbooks that teach tolera.....
How sustainable is Middle Eastern détente? That is the $64,000 question. The answer is probab.....
Qatar has begun to cleanse its schoolbooks of supremacist, racist or derogatory references as well a.....
Long banned, Christmas has finally, at least tacitly, arrived in Saudi Arabia; just don’t use .....
Increasingly, compliance with US sanctions against Iran could emerge as a litmus test of the United .....
Footballers with diametrically opposed views on homosexuality and alcohol consumption have sparked h.....
Saudi Islamic affairs minister Abdullatif bin Abdulaziz al-Sheikh has ordered imams in the kingdom t.....
The United States has signalled in advance of next week’s Summit for Democracy that it is unli.....
A cursory look at Saudi Arabia and Iran suggests that emphasizing human rights in US foreign policy .....
When seven-time Formula One world champion Lewis Hamilton wore a helmet this weekend featuring the c.....
It has been a good week for United Arab Emirates Crown Prince Mohammed bin Zayed. Headline-grabbing,.....
Just in case there were any doubts, Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu demonstrated with his .....
Sudan is the exception to the rule in the United Arab Emirates’ counterrevolutionary playbook......
Former Saudi intelligence chief Prince Turki AlFaisal Al Saud must have gotten his tenses mixed up w.....
An Indonesian promise to work with the United Arab Emirates to promote ‘moderate’ Islam .....
As Middle Eastern states attempt to manage their political and security differences, Muslim-majority.....
The future of US engagement in the Middle East hangs in the balance. Two decades of forever war in A.....
It may not have been planned or coordinated but efforts by Middle Eastern states to dial down tensio.....
Gulf States are in a pickle. They fear that the emerging parameters of a reconfigured US commitment .....
Two separate developments involving improved relations between Sunni and Shiite Muslims and women&rs.....
On their way from Tel Aviv airport to Jerusalem in 1977 then Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Yigael Ya.....
Saudi and Emirati efforts to define ‘moderate’ Islam as socially more liberal while bein.....
Turkish state-run television appears to have not gotten the message: Turkey and the United Arab Emir.....
The Taliban takeover of Afghanistan perpetuates a paradigm of failed governance in the Muslim world .....
Israel’s first post-Netanyahu government is seeking to rebuild fractured relations with the Je.....
Taliban advances in Afghanistan shift the Central Asian playing field on which China, India and the .....
Boasting an almost 1,000-kilometre border with Iran and a history of troubled relations between the .....
This month’s indictment of a billionaire, one-time advisor and close associate of former US Pr.....
A recent analysis of Middle Eastern states’ interventionist policies suggests that misguided b.....
The United States and Iran seem to be hardening their positions in advance of a resumption of negoti.....
A recent unprecedented alliance between Muslims and Evangelicals takes on added significance in a wo.....
China may have no short-term interest in contributing to guaranteeing security in parts of a swath o.....
The rise of hard-line President-elect Ebrahim Raisi has prompted some analysts to counterintuitively.....
US President Joe Biden may have little appetite for Israeli-Palestinian peace making but seems deter.....
Recent announcements by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of plans to turn the kingdom into a transpo.....
Saudi Arabia has stepped up efforts to outflank the United Arab Emirates and Qatar as the Gulf&rsquo.....
Eager to enhance its negotiating leverage with the United States and Europe, Iran is projecting immi.....
Former Crown Prince Hamzah bin Hussein has papered over a rare public dispute in the ruling Jordania.....
Former Crown Prince Hamzah bin Hussein has papered over a rare public dispute in the ruling Jordania.....
In a sign of the times, Turkish schoolbooks have replaced Saudi texts as the bull’s eye of cri.....
Saudi Sheikh Salman al-Awdah, a popular but controversial religious scholar who has been mostly in s.....
Recent clashes in the Iranian province of Sistan and Balochistan highlight Iran’s vulnerabilit.....
Two decades of snail pace revisions of Saudi schoolbooks aimed at removing supremacist references to.....
A little acknowledged provision of the 2015 international agreement that curbed Iran’s nuclear.....
Religion scholar Esra Ozyurek has a knack for identifying trends that ring warning bells about where.....
A projected sharp reduction in trade between the United States and China in the next two years coupl.....
Public debates about China’s Middle East policy are as much internal Chinese discussions as th.....
Saudi Arabia has taken multiple steps to polish its tarnished image in advance of this weekend&rsquo.....
An Emirati offer to invest in Israel’s most controversial soccer club could serve as a figurat.....
A close read of the agreement between the United Arab Emirates and Israel suggests that the Jewish s.....
A rift between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia throws into sharp relief deepening fissures in the Muslim w.....
Rare polling of public opinion in Saudi Arabia suggests that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman may be.....
China is contemplating greater political engagement in the Middle East in what would constitute a br.....
Europe is progressively being sucked into the Middle East and North Africa’s myriad conflicts......
China looms large as a potentially key player alongside Russia and Iran in President Bashas al-Assad.....
Civilizationalist leaders, who seek religious legitimacy, cater to a religious support base or initi.....
A decision by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and non-OPEC producers like R.....
The Coronavirus pandemic points a finger not only at the colossal global collapse of responsible pub.....
Syria’s announcement of its first COVID-19 case highlights the public health threat posed by w.....
The fight in this week’s Democratic primaries may have been about who confronts Donald J. Trum.....
A podcast version of this story is available on Sound cloud, ITunes, Spotify, Stitcher, Tune In, Spe.....
Saudi Arabia may have been getting more than it bargained for when authorities in Khujand, Tajikista.....
At the core of US president Donald J. Trump’s maximum pressure campaign against Iran lies the .....
The Iranian port city of Bandar-e-Mahshahr has emerged as the scene of some of the worst violence in.....
Saudi efforts to negotiate an end to the Yemen war in a bid to open a dialogue with Iran could call .....
China is manoeuvring to avoid being sucked into the Middle East’s numerous disputes amid mount.....
Fears of a potential military conflict with Iran may have opened the door to a Saudi-Iranian dialogu.....
By the law of unintended consequences, US President Donald J. Trump’s mix of uncritical and cy.....
Little suggests that fabulously wealthy Gulf States and their Middle Eastern and North African benef.....
A controversial former security official and Abu Dhabi-based political operator, Mohammed Dahlan, ha.....
Russia, backed by China, hoping to exploit mounting doubts in the Gulf about the reliability of the .....
China and Russia are as much allies as they are rivals. A joint Tajik-Chinese military exercise in a.....
Thought that sectarianism was a pillar of the Saud Iranian rivalry? Think again, think Kashmir where.....
These are tough times for Saudi Arabia. The drama enveloping the killing of journalist Jamal Khas.....
Saudi plans to become a major gas exporter within a decade raise questions about what the .....
A Turkish-Chinese spat as a result of Turkish criticism of China’s crackdown on Turkic Mu.....
This week’s suicide attack on Revolutionary Guards in Iran’s south-eastern province of S.....
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s three-nation tour of Asia is as much about demonstrat.....
It may be reading tea leaves but analysis of the walk-up to Saudi crown prince Mohammed bin Salman&r.....
Alarm bells went off last September in Washington's corridors of power when John Bolton&rsq.....
US President Donald J. Trump’s threat to devastate Turkey’s economy if Turkish troo.....
Pakistan is traversing minefields as it concludes agreements on investment, balance of payments supp.....
A heavy soup made of pulled noodles, meat, and vegetables symbolizes Central Asia’s close cult.....
As far as Gulf leaders are concerned, President Donald J. Trump demonstrated with his announced.....
When President Recep Tayyip Erdogan recently declared that Turkey was “the only country that c.....
A draft US Senate resolution describing Saudi policy in the Middle East as a "wrecking ball&quo.....
As Saudi crown prince Mohammed bin Salman tours friendly Arab nations in advance of the Group of 20 .....
Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan lands in Beijing on November 3, the latest head of government to.....
Saudi Arabia and Turkey, despite being on opposite sides of Middle Eastern divides, are cooperating .....
It’s easy to dismiss Iranian denunciations of the United States and its Middle Eastern allies .....
An attack on a military parade in the southern Iranian city of Ahwaz is likely to prompt Iranian ret.....
A Financial Action Task Force (FATF) report criticizing Saudi Arabia’s anti-money laundering a.....
Desperate for funding to fend off a financial crisis fuelled in part by mounting debt to China, Paki.....
Iran has raised the spectre of a US-Saudi effort to destabilize the country by exploiting .....
A possible ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, the Islamist group that controls the Gaza S.....
With multiple Middle Eastern disputes threatening to spill out of control, United Arab Emirates mini.....
Embattled former Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak was the main loser in last month&rsq.....
Lurking in the background of a Saudi-Moroccan spat over World Cup hosting rights and the Gulf crisis.....
Amid ever closer cooperation with Saudi Arabia, Israel’s military appears to be adopting the k.....
Mounting anger and discontent is simmering across the Arab world much like it did in the w.....
Argentina’s cancellation of a friendly against Israel because of Israeli attempts to exploit t.....
Conventional wisdom has it that China stands to benefit from the US withdrawal from the 2015 interna.....
Saudi Arabia’s bitter rivalry with Iran has spilled onto Asian soccer pitches with t.....
A controversy in Algeria over the growing popularity of Saudi-inspired Salafi scholars spotlights th.....
Subtle shifts in Chinese energy imports suggest that China may be able to exert influence in the Mid.....
Egyptian general-turned-president Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi won a second term virtually unchallenged in w.....
Protests have erupted in Iran’s oil-rich province of Khuzestan barely three months after the I.....
Debilitating hostility between Saudi Arabia and Iran is about lots of things, not least who will hav.....
Saudi Arabia, in an indication that it is serious about shaving off the sharp edges of its Sunni Mus.....
The Middle East has a knack for sucking external powers into its conflicts. China’s ventures i.....
A Saudi draft law could constitute a first indication that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s .....
Turkish allegations of Saudi, Emirati and Egyptian support for the outlawed Kurdish Workers Party (P.....
Prominent US constitutional lawyer and scholar Alan M. Dershowitz raised eyebrows when he described .....
Plans to open a Salafi missionary centre in the Yemeni province of Al Mahrah on the border with Oman.....
If week-long anti-government protests in Iran exposed the Islamic republic’s deep-se.....
Kuwaiti billionaire Maan al-Sanea should have seen it coming after Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin S.....
Long-standing Saudi efforts to dominate the pan-Arab media landscape appear to have moved into high .....